In a recent incident that has garnered widespread attention, two nurses from Bankstown Hospital in Sydney were suspended today after appearing in a social media video making anti-Semitic remarks and threatening to harm Israeli patients.
The video, which surfaced on platforms like Chatroulette, depicted the nurses, identifiable by their NSW Health uniforms, expressing intentions to refuse treatment to Israeli individuals and even cause them harm. NSW Health Minister Ryan Park condemned the behaviour as “vile, disgusting and appalling” and assured that a thorough investigation is underway.
This incident highlights the need for employers to understand their disciplinary options when employees violate or breach workplace policies and employment terms, ensuring appropriate action is taken while maintaining legal compliance and procedural fairness.
While the natural reaction to such behaviour is to demand immediate termination, the basic rules of Procedural Fairness continue to apply. Employers must navigate these situations carefully to maintain workplace integrity, uphold legal standards, and protect their organisation’s reputation.
Types of Employee Misconduct
Broadly speaking, employee misconduct generally falls into two categories: general and gross misconduct.
General Misconduct:
This includes minor infractions such as tardiness, unauthorised absence, or misuse of company resources. These actions are typically not malicious but can be objectively categorised as disrupting workplace harmony. Employers often address general misconduct through verbal or written warnings, suspension, or additional training.
Gross Misconduct:
This encompasses serious infractions that undermine the employer-employee relationship, such as theft, fraud, harassment, or serious breaches of company policy. In cases of gross misconduct, immediate suspension or termination may be warranted.
The conduct, which has amassed widespread attention, is likely to be regarded as serious misconduct because it constitutes a fundamental breach of trust between the employees and their employer, NSW Health. Under Australian employment law, serious misconduct is defined as behaviour that is wilful or deliberate and inconsistent with the continuation of the employment contract.
Key Reasons this Conduct Qualifies as Serious Misconduct:
At first glance, the behaviour is undeniably alarming. The video capturing the interaction is publicly accessible and speaks for itself. The protagonists involved are clearly identifiable in their NSW Health uniforms, presenting themselves as employees of the NSW Health organisation. While further details may emerge over time, the recorded exchange is deeply troubling and casts a shadow over the professionalism expected of NSW Health employees.
1. Breach of Workplace Policies & Ethics: NSW Health employees are expected to provide care impartially, and the NSW Health employee’s threats to harm patients based on nationality or ethnicity violate fundamental ethical and professional standards.
2. Risk to Patient Safety: Stating an intent to deny or harm patients undermines public trust in healthcare services and endangers patient welfare.
3. Serious Repetitional Damage: The video’s viral nature damages NSW Health’s integrity, potentially impacting public confidence and employer reputation.
4. Breach of Anti-Discrimination & Harassment Laws: The remarks could be considered unlawful discrimination under the Anti-Discrimination Act 1977 (NSW) and Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), exposing the employer to liability.
Given these factors, NSW Health would likely consider immediate termination justified under the serious misconduct provisions in employment contracts and workplace law.
Nevertheless, NSW Health is expected to conduct an internal investigation before reaching a final decision. The employees will likely be stood down pending the outcome of the investigation. Regardless of the nature or severity of the incident, employees are entitled to procedural fairness.
Disciplinary Procedures
When addressing multiple breaches, it’s essential for employers to follow a structured disciplinary procedure to ensure fairness and legal compliance. A typical process includes:
Employers must follow a structured disciplinary process to uphold fairness and legal compliance when dealing with multiple breaches. A standard procedure includes:
1. Investigation: Conduct a thorough investigation to gather facts and determine the severity of the misconduct. This may involve reviewing evidence, interviewing witnesses, and documenting findings.
2. Disciplinary Meeting: If the investigation reveals sufficient evidence of misconduct, invite the employee to a disciplinary meeting. Provide them with details of the allegations and allow them to present their side of the story.
3. Decision & Action: After considering all information, decide on the appropriate disciplinary action. Depending on the severity and frequency of the breaches, this could range from a formal warning to termination.
4. Appeal Process: If the employee believes the decision was unjust, offer them an opportunity to appeal. To ensure objectivity, an impartial party should handle the appeal.
Legal Considerations
Regardless of the nature of the infraction or breach, the following considerations need to be taken into account:
1. Consistency: Apply disciplinary actions uniformly to avoid discrimination or unfair treatment claims.
2. Documentation: Maintain detailed records of all incidents, investigations, and disciplinary actions to provide evidence in case of legal disputes.
3. Policy Adherence: Ensure that any disciplinary action aligns with and meets your company’s established policies and procedures. Deviating from these can lead to legal challenges.
Preparing the Workplace & Attending to Risk
To prevent incidents of misconduct, we always recommend that employers:
-
Establish Clear Policies: Develop comprehensive policies outlining acceptable behaviour and the consequences of violations.
-
Training: Regularly train employees on company policies, ethical standards, and the importance of maintaining a respectful workplace.
-
Open Communication: Foster an environment where employees feel comfortable reporting concerns without fear of retaliation.
The recent incident involving the Sydney nurses is a powerful reminder of the serious consequences of employee misconduct. Employers can effectively address breaches by enforcing strong disciplinary procedures and adhering to legal standards while safeguarding their organisations from potential risks.
Protecting Workplace Integrity
Madison Marcus: Expert Guidance in Workplace Misconduct & Compliance
At Madison Marcus, our Employment Law Division provides expert guidance in handling complex workplace misconduct cases, ensuring employers take decisive action while upholding procedural fairness and legal compliance. We assist in:
-
Navigating disciplinary procedures to address breaches effectively.
-
Mitigating legal and reputational risks through proactive workplace policies.
-
Conducting thorough investigations to support fair and defensible decision-making.
-
Ensuring compliance with employment laws, anti-discrimination regulations, and workplace ethics.
By partnering with Madison Marcus, employers can confidently manage misconduct cases while protecting their organisation’s integrity.
